Photoshop fun

I have a few images of our lovely grandchildren from  a studio shoot we did a few weeks ago. While I had a bit of time on my hands last night I decided to play about in photoshop to see what I could come up with as a birthday gift for my daughter in law. Family opinion is divided as to which picture would be  the better option.  I know which one I prefer, what do you think?

As it turned out, daughter in law didn't want either of them, she had her own ideas. Oh well, can't win 'em all!